Smarter PPC Strategy for Seasonal Credit Union Campaigns

Seasonal campaigns for credit unions often get rushed out the door: quick launch, quick spend, and a vague hope that something sticks. But in competitive financial markets, that kind of approach usually leads to wasted budget and underwhelming performance.

This article walks through a more intentional strategy we’ve been applying at Geear. It focuses on smarter bidding, meaningful goal setting, and campaign structures that match how members actually behave. All built to help seasonal promos (like holiday or year-end offers) drive real results, even within short timelines.

1. The Usual Trap: Max Clicks and Misleading Conversions

It’s common to launch seasonal campaigns on Max Clicks because it’s quick and gets traffic flowing. But the volume doesn’t mean much when it’s not converting. On top of that, campaigns are often tied to soft goals like time on site or pageviews: things Google can optimize for easily, but that don’t actually reflect intent.

For short-term promos, like skip-a-pay offers or holiday loan pushes, there’s just not enough time to let the algorithm figure things out. Waiting to gather enough data before switching to Max Conversions often means you’re halfway through the promo window before anything starts to work.

2. A Better Start: Max Conversions + Smart Goals From Day One

Instead of defaulting to Max Clicks, we’ve started launching promos with Max Conversions right out of the gate and it’s helped campaigns ramp up faster. The key is using a custom goal set that tells Google exactly what to prioritize, even if you’re not tracking lower-funnel outcomes like funded loans.

Because these campaigns are short-term, we’re focusing on micro- and mid-funnel actions that still show clear intent. These include:

• Application form starts
• Completed lead forms
• Tracked phone calls from ads

Including calls gives us something to optimize toward while waiting for deeper actions that take longer. We’re also intentional about excluding fluff like no page views, scroll depth, or session time goals that muddy the signals. 

The best part? These higher-funnel actions often still lead directly to completed applications and eventually funded loans. We can still review that data in reporting and begin optimizing for it directly once volume ramps up! 

3. Structure Your Campaigns for the Way People Search

A well-structured campaign isn’t just about bidding, it’s about alignment.

If the product is highly seasonal, the campaign structure should reflect that. For example, don’t lump a holiday auto loan push with winter imagery into the same campaign or asset group as evergreen checking messaging.

We recommend separating campaigns or asset groups by:

• Product type (checking vs. HELOCs)
• Member type (new vs. existing)
• Region or branch

This gives you more optimization control and tells a clearer story when you’re reviewing results.

We also use urgency-driven language in ad copy (e.g., “Limited-Time Rate Ends 12/31”) and lean on landing pages for promo-specific details like eligibility, rate restrictions, or deadlines.

4. Tips and Tricks That Actually Work

• Geo-target by counties,  not entire DMAs or states
• Build backwards from your promo end date;  launch early!
• Check search terms weekly — promos often trigger odd queries
  
  

Most importantly, treat every promo like a micro-experiment. You don’t need a perfect A/B test. Just track:

• What messages resonate?
• Which CTAs convert?
• Where does performance drop off?
  
  

This will make your next campaign sharper.

5. What This Means for Credit Union PPC Strategy

Promos shouldn’t be one-and-done efforts. The goal is to build a repeatable campaign structure you can adjust and improve with each run, not start from scratch every time. That means launching with Max Conversions from the start, using goal setups that reflect real member intent, and aligning your messaging and structure with the specific actions you want users to take.

When you give Google the right signals and structure from day one, you create a smarter foundation that continues to work harder for you over time, with no big experiments required.

Final Thoughts

Seasonal campaigns move fast, but that doesn’t mean they should be rushed. The difference between a promo that quietly drains spend and one that actually performs usually comes down to how intentional you are with goals,  structure, and how you speak to your audience. 

When you launch with clear conversion signals, mirror how real members search, and treat every campaign as something you can learn from and build on, you’re not just running a promotion. You’re building smarter, stronger paid media habits that carry forward into every season.

Learn What Our Advertising Experts Can Do For You. Click here to schedule a call with your team.